All of the “major” counts look reasonable but there is a BIG problem with page counts. We started the site in April, 2016. In September, 2016 we had page counts on two pages as follows:
PV Page: 2,783
Results Page: 2,450
Also, the Page View count was 23,199.
As of today:
PV Page: 718
Results Page: 55
But the total Page Views is at 88,260, which looks very reasonable compared to September, 2016.
AND, by going to analysis.google.com, I found:
PV Page: 11,821
Results Page: 1,456
NOTICE that Google Analytics “Result Page” is less than the September, 2016 count!!!
Can you post some screenshots? Also it will be awesome if you could avoid acronyms and mention the exact reports you’re looking at. The plugin has a bunch of reports (Dashboard Widget, Frontend Reports, Posts/Pages Backend Reports, Sidebar Widget).